After like 18 or 20 intermittently painful years of fighting very fierce internal battles with myself, I’m going to hereby declare ala Paul Revere/the Constitution/Jury Duty that The Peach Pit is total bullshit. Oh, you don’t know what I’m talking about senior citizens, babies, immigrants, people who were homeless in the 90s? I’m talking about the popular Nat-owned diner in LA, CA wherein students from West Beverly High, including those named Brenda Walsh, Brandon Walsh, Dylan McKay, Kelly Taylor, Donna Martin (pre- and post-graduates!), Steve Sanders, David Silver, ETCETERA, went to hang out after school, at night, on weekends, to conduct interviews with tabloid journalists, to break up with each other, to cry after being stood up by their fathers while wearing sexy prosti dresses, to entertain beefcakey midwestern American boys while pretending to be French, ETCETERA. This all happened on a little show that some of us (those who can read/hear/talk/speak l’anglais) called Beverly Hills, 90210. AKA, the questionably/last/only unfathomably wonderful teenage soap-drama television show. UNFATHOMABLY WONDERFUL.

Note the 1950s exterior, we'll get to that in a sec.
Anyway, you could probably compare The Peach Pit to The Max aka the oft-frequented hangout for Saved By the Bell’s Bayside High students. (Sidenote 1: Yes, Tiffani Amber Thiessen appeared on both shows.) (Sidenote 2: Yes spellcheck red-underlines her full name.)(Sidenote 3: Your eyes may/may not deceive you, depending on what you thought, but the fact is that while T.A.T. has a very round, chipmunk-with-a-coke-bloat face, she was never actually overweight, or even chunky. You can tell by analyzing a decade of her midriff-bearing publicity photos, like I did.) Superficially, The Max and The Peach Pit seem like the same kind of deal. They were both diners with vinyl furniture and packed to capacity with Californian high school kids, unless one of the most important kids (i.e. Zack i.e. Brandon) needed to reserve it at apparently no charge for a private meeting/date/confrontation/dance-off.
Don’t be fooled. They are not so similar. Here are the reasons why I am willing to buy into The Max:
1. Those kids lived in Bayside, CA. That’s like, fake. Obviously it was supposed to be somewhere in southern California, but who knows what kind of town it was? Could have been some rural beach community 500 miles outside civilization and/or any kind of city life. Maybe they were living in some sort of surfing commune that was originally built by Mr. Belding and his wife in the 60s. Who knows? What I’m saying is that The Max could have easily been the coolest, hippest, raddest place around and so I can understand why they might want to hang out there.
2. Those kids were in high school for I think like 72 years. So even if it wasn’t the coolest, hippest, raddest place around, they were obviously too dumb to figure it out.
Like I said, it took me a good 74% of my life to decide that unlike The Max, The Peach Pit is pure bullshit. This isn’t the outcome I wanted, believe me. I didn’t arrive at this unfortunate conclusion without a lot of thought and some very detailed, well-researched pro/con, pos/neg, yes/no lists. You will read them now.
Reasons Why The Peach Pit is Bullshit:
1. These kids live in Beverly Hills, California. AKA Los Angeles California. You are telling me that despite all 1,000,000 other options for cuisine, clubs for partying, locales for break-ups, gathering spots for gossip, etc, they chose a 1950s-themed diner run by a borderline senior citizen that doesn’t sell any coke other than a-cola? Negative. I mean I grew up in a New Jersey town with like 7 diners to choose from, and I still made the 25 minute trek to NYC every weekend to avoid jukeboxes and meth head waitresses.
2. What teenager in the 1990s was super into 1950s music? None of them, that’s the answer! Like they were ever listening to Brown-Eyed Girl or Pretty Woman or wearing Poodle skirts. Never! They liked the hippity hop! I mean granted, David Silver’s music sounded like an autistic kid shrieking at a synthesized fire alarm, but it definitely bore no resemblance to Doo Wop. I mean a ditty from the ’50s is okay as a once a year novelty, but every night? Negative.
3. I repeat there were no drugs sold at The Peach Pit.
4. Everyone on that show was strongly anorexic. Definitely not eating fries or other intensely caloric diner foods on the regular.
5. Don’t you love how they gave Donna a learning disability to make up for Tori Spelling? (whoopsie, off topic but right?!?!?!?!)
6. The Peach Pit was in Pasadena! I mean you could tell that wasn’t BH. BH doesn’t have streets like that! Come ON. Give me a break. Like they really went to Pasadena after school everyday when there weren’t even going to be any speedballs waiting for them. Pls.
Reasons Why The Peach Pit Might Not Be Bullshit:
1. None.
This post was brought to you by the creepy weird gap in Shannen Doherty’s teeth.